Apple Podcasts 
Spotify 
Amazon Music 
YouTube 
PocketCasts 
iHeartRadio 
Overcast 
Deezer 
RSS Feed STARSET - a n n 1 h 1 l a t 1 0 n - Review
Key Takeaways
- Derek and John offer sharply contrasting opinions on Starset Annihilation, debating whether its massive futuristic production is genuinely gripping or merely packaged metal.
- John defends the track's blend of melodic vocals, chunky riffs, and ambient electronics, praising Dustin Bates' intentional creative vision.
- Derek pushes back by calling the song boring, sparking a deeper conversation about the fine line between modern metal heaviness and accessibility.
- The hosts break down the intricate production elements behind the track, highlighting Randy Slaugh's contributions to the layered electronic programming and textures.
- The episode broadens its scope to discuss other heavy music releases, including Ghost's live '2 Big to Rig' drop and Down's 'Blood Oath'.
Starset’s Annihilation sounds huge, polished, and futuristic - but is it actually gripping, or just packaged metal? Derek and John get into the heart of what makes the track work for one listener and fall flat for another, using it as a launchpad for a bigger conversation about modern metal, production, and what actually makes a song hit.
John breaks down why Starset’s mix of melodic vocals, chunky riffs, electronic texture, and ambient atmosphere works so well, and why Dustin Bates’ vision feels so intentional. Derek pushes back, calling the song boring while still acknowledging the band’s sonic power. They talk through the role of lyrics versus vocals, and dig into the production team behind the band’s layered sound. From Randy Slaugh’s programming and texturing work to the way modern metal balances heaviness with accessibility, this episode gets into the details that separate a forgettable track from a real statement.
They also widen the lens to cover other new releases and legacy bands that are still shaping heavy music now - including Ghost’s live "2 Big to Rig" release, Down’s "Blood Oath," and a surprisingly thoughtful take on what it means for older bands to keep crushing it without pretending they’re still 20 years old.
Perfect for metal fans who like honest reactions, sharp opinions, and deep cuts on what makes a track work - or fail. If you care about riffs, texture, vocals, and the state of modern heavy music, this one hits.
www.shittalkreviews.com
Spotify - https://tinyurl.com/STR-Spotify
Apple Podcasts - https://tinyurl.com/STR-Apple-Podcasts
#starset #annihilation #starsetsociety #metal #cinematicmetal #starsetonline #dustinbates #hardrock #alternativemetal #metalmusic #scifi #cinematicrock #space #dystopian
Drop us a line! What bands do you want us to review? Who should we interview next?
Frequently Asked Questions
What do the hosts think of Starset Annihilation?
The hosts are divided; John praises the track's cinematic blend of chunky riffs, electronic textures, and melodic vocals, while Derek finds the song a bit boring despite its sonic power.
Who is behind the production and programming on Starset's tracks?
The episode highlights producer and programmer Randy Slaugh for his work on the band's heavily layered sonic textures and cinematic soundscapes.
What other bands are discussed on this episode of Sh!t Talk Reviews?
Alongside the Starset Annihilation review, the hosts discuss Ghost's live release '2 Big to Rig' and Down's track 'Blood Oath'.